Every few weeks someone asks me a version of the same question. Should I go with a freelancer or an agency?
They usually expect me to say freelancer. I am one. But the honest answer is that both work, both fail, and the thing that actually decides it is rarely the thing people are arguing about.
So here’s the fair version, including the parts that don’t flatter me.
What agencies are genuinely good at
Let’s start with the case for the other side, because it’s a real one.
A team, not a person. Designer, developer, copywriter, SEO, ads specialist. When a project needs five skills at once and needs them this month, an agency has all five already on the payroll.
They don’t vanish. If someone quits mid-project, someone else picks up the file. Annual leave doesn’t stop your build.
Process. Briefs, timelines, QA, sign-off stages. When there are eight stakeholders and a board presentation, that structure earns its keep.
Capacity. Multi-site rollouts, a rebrand that spans print and digital, a campaign locked to a fixed launch date. That’s agency territory and I’ll say so.
If you’re a national brand with an internal marketing team and a serious budget, hire an agency. I’d tell you that to your face.
Where agencies tend to fall down
You meet the salesperson, not the builder. The person who impressed you in the pitch meeting is usually not the person writing your code. You often never meet them.
Layers. Your request goes to an account manager, who logs it, who briefs a project manager, who queues it for a developer. A ten-minute change can take a week and a half.
Turnover. Account managers move on. Every time yours does, you explain your business again from scratch.
Overheads are in your quote. Office space, sales staff, management, the coffee machine. None of it makes your website better, all of it is priced in.
Small jobs sit at the bottom of the pile. If you’re not the biggest client that month, you’ll feel it.
Where freelancers win
One conversation. You talk to the person doing the work. Nothing gets lost in translation because there’s no translation.
Speed on small things. A text change, a new page, a broken form. Message me, it’s usually done the same day.
More of your budget goes into the work. Lower overheads, fewer people to pay out of the same quote.
Continuity, if you pick well. Stay with the same freelancer for five years and they know your business, your history, why that odd redirect exists, and which plugin broke everything in 2023.
The honest problems with freelancers
This is the part most freelancers skip on their own blog. I’d rather you hear it from me.
One person is one point of failure. Holidays, illness, family emergencies. If your freelancer has no plan for that, you have no plan for that.
Breadth is genuinely hard. Plenty of excellent developers can’t write a headline. Plenty of excellent designers have never configured a mail record. A freelancer who claims to be world-class at everything is telling you something about their honesty, not their skills.
There’s a capacity ceiling. One person can only build so much at once. A twelve-site rollout with a hard deadline isn’t a solo job.
And then there’s the disappearing act. The site launches, the final invoice gets paid, and the developer evaporates. Emails unanswered. Calls unreturned. Left on seen.
That last one is the reason most people end up talking to me in the first place.
The bit almost nobody writes about: what happens after launch
Here’s what I think the whole freelancer-versus-agency debate gets wrong. It treats a website like something you buy, when a website is something you run.
Launch day isn’t the finish line. It’s the start of the actual relationship. In the first twelve months alone, all of this lands on someone’s desk:
- The domain comes up for renewal, and the notice goes to an email address nobody has checked since 2019
- Hosting needs paying, and eventually the site outgrows the plan it was set up on
- WordPress core, the theme and every plugin need updating, over and over
- Backups need running, and more importantly, need testing
- The SSL certificate expires and Chrome starts warning visitors away
- Google changes something and rankings drift
- The contact form quietly stops delivering and you don’t find out for six weeks
- Business emails start landing in spam
- Someone leaves a review you need to respond to
Most of the sites I get called in to rescue weren’t badly built. They were just left alone. Neglect is how a good website becomes a hacked one, and it happens gradually enough that nobody notices until it’s a Saturday afternoon and the site is down.
An agency will handle all of that. They’ll also charge you a retainer for it, and you’ll still be talking to an account manager.
How I work: one contact, agency-level cover
I built my setup specifically around that gap. You get one person to call, and behind that, the same range of services you’d get from a small agency.
Under one roof:
For the pieces that need a specialist beyond me, I work with a small network of people I’ve worked with for years. You still deal with me. I just don’t pretend to be five people.
Practically, it means you send one message when something breaks, and you don’t have to work out whose fault it is first. Is it hosting, the theme, DNS, or the plugin that updated last night? Not your problem to diagnose.
On the “what if you get hit by a bus” question
It’s a fair question and you should ask it of any freelancer.
My answer: everything is in your name. Your domain, your hosting account, your Google accounts, your Meta business manager. I have access to work on them. I don’t own them. If you ever want to move to someone else, you take the lot with you and there’s no negotiation about it.
A freelancer who holds your logins hostage isn’t a freelancer. That’s a hostage situation, and it’s more common than it should be.
Questions to ask whoever you hire
Take this list to your next quote, agency or freelancer. The answers tell you more than the portfolio does.
- Who actually does the work, and will I speak to them?
- What’s covered after launch, and what’s billed separately?
- Whose name will the domain and hosting be in?
- What happens if you’re unavailable for two weeks?
- If we part ways, do I get my files, my database and every login?
- Who do I call when the site goes down on a Saturday?
Anyone who gets uncomfortable at question three or five has just answered question six for you.
So which should you choose?
Go with an agency if you’ve got an internal marketing team to manage them, a campaign running across several channels at once, a fixed launch date with real money behind it, or a procurement process that requires a company rather than a sole trader.
Go with a freelancer if you’re a small or medium business, you want one person who knows your setup, you’d rather your budget went into the work than the overheads, and you value being able to text someone and get an answer.
Either way, judge them on year two, not on the pitch. Anyone can build you a website. The question is who’s still answering the phone eighteen months later when something breaks at the worst possible time.
A few common questions
Is a freelancer cheaper than an agency? Usually, yes, because the overheads are lower. But cheap isn’t the point. A cheap site that gets neglected costs more to fix than it saved you. If you want real numbers, here’s how much a website costs in Australia.
Can one freelancer really cover design, development, SEO and ads? Some can, most can’t, and you should ask for examples of each rather than taking anyone’s word for it. Twelve years in, I do the ones I’m genuinely good at and bring in people I trust for the rest.
What if I already have a website and a developer who’s gone quiet? That’s a normal starting point, not an awkward one. Most of my ongoing clients came to me that way. As long as you can get access to your domain and hosting, it’s usually straightforward to pick up.
Do I have to move my hosting to work with you? No. It’s often easier if you do, but I’ll work with what you’ve got.
If you’d rather just get on with running your business
That’s the actual pitch. Not “freelancers are better than agencies”, because they’re not, always. The pitch is that your website, your hosting, your domain, your search rankings and your ads shouldn’t be six separate things you have to remember to worry about.
Hand them over and get back to work. That’s the job I do as a freelance web developer in Sydney.
Get in touch or call 0410 810 380. Happy to give you a straight answer even if the straight answer is that you’d be better off with an agency.